By Michael Lanza
Our group of three adults and six teenagers crossed the 9,200-foot pass on the Alice-Toxaway Divide, separating Alice and Twin lakes from Toxaway Lake, on our third straight bluebird August afternoon backpacking in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains. Before us, an arc of spires and jagged peaks wrapped around a pair of alpine lakes appropriately named Twin Lakes. And although I had hiked over this pass many times before, I stopped in my tracks and just stared at our vista. Perhaps most impressively, even the jaded teens with us found themselves awestruck, too.
Living in Idaho for over 20 years now, I’ve hiked most of the trails in the Sawtooths over the course of at least 20 trips there, and climbed a number of peaks. While there remain many climbs and off-trail areas I want to explore, I’ve gotten to know much of the range quite well. And having had the good fortune of dayhiking and backpacking in some of the prettiest mountain ranges in the country over the past three decades—including the 10 years I spent as the Northwest Editor of Backpacker magazine and even longer running this blog—I’ve become convinced that few rival the Sawtooths for their jagged granite peaks and skylines and abundance of lovely alpine lakes.
I never tire of exploring the Sawtooths.
Hi, I’m Michael Lanza, creator of The Big Outside. Click here to sign up for my FREE email newsletter. Join The Big Outside to get full access to all of my blog’s stories. Click here for my e-guides to classic backpacking trips. Click here to learn how I can help you plan your next trip.
This article describes several favorite dayhikes and backpacking trips in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains, and includes links to several stories about trips I have taken in the Sawtooths (some of which require a paid subscription to The Big Outside to read in full). See my expert e-guide “The Best Backpacking Trip in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains” and my Custom Trip Planning page to learn how I can help you plan your trip in the Sawtooths or any other trip you read about at The Big Outside.
Click any photo below to read about that trip. Please tell me what you think of these hikes or share your own questions or suggested hikes in the comments section at the bottom of this story; I try to respond to all comments.
Dayhikes
Much of the best scenery in the Sawtooths lies far enough from roads to be hard to reach in a day, but there are highlights you can knock off in several hours—or at least between sunrise and sunset.
Sawtooth Lake
Very photogenic Sawtooth Lake is one of the most-visited corners of the Sawtooths; expect to see other hikers here on nice summer weekends and to compete for campsites with backpackers. At 8,430 feet, it’s about 8.5 miles round-trip and 1,700 vertical feet from the Iron Creek Trailhead. The trail up the Iron Creek Valley ascends past a long, pinnacled ridge, and you can make a short side trip en route to Alpine Lake, tucked in a bowl of rock.
Get an early start because the glassy waters of Sawtooth Lake on a calm morning offer up an unforgettable mirror image of Mount Regan. Scramble the steep but non-technical west face of 9,861-foot Alpine Peak for the best perspective on the natural stone bathtub the lake sits in.
Find your next adventure in your Inbox. Sign up for my FREE email newsletter now.
Baron Divide
The pass known as Baron Divide, at over 9,000 feet along the high ridge separating the gorgeous Baron Lakes basin from the valley of Redfish Lake Creek, is a stout but doable dayhike from the Redfish Inlet transfer camp boat landing at the southwest corner of Redfish Lake. At some 14 miles round-trip, with about 2,700 feet of elevation gain and loss, it’s no light stroll. But the trails are good all the way, the grade rarely gets difficult, and the scenery is top-notch beginning with the boat shuttle across Redfish Lake.
At Redfish Lake Lodge, two miles off ID 75 about five miles south of Stanley, go to the marina and get the 10-minute boat shuttle across the lake. On the other side of the lake, follow trail signs up the Redfish Lake Creek Valley toward Alpine Lake and Cramer Lakes. About three miles up, at Flatrock Junction, turn north onto Trail 101 toward Alpine Lake and the Baron Lakes; this switchbacks that follow are arguably the hottest and toughest stretch of the hike, before you reenter forest for a while.
Eventually, the trail emerges from the forest, passes a pretty tarn, and reaches the alpine pass at Baron Divide, with sweeping views of the peaks to either side, including the serrated ridge of Monte Verita and Warbonnet Peak. Return the way you came.
I can help you plan any trip you read about at my blog. Find out more here.
Thompson Peak
Thompson Peak, crown of the Sawtooth Range at 10,751 feet, can be tagged on a rugged, partly off-trail hike of about 13 miles and 4,200 vertical feet round-trip. A fun, easy, short, third-class scramble at the very top places you on a blocky summit with space for just a few people and head-spinning drop-offs on all sides. See more photos in my story “Roof of Idaho’s Sawtooths: Hiking Thompson Peak.”
From Redfish Trailhead, right before Redfish Lake Lodge, follow Trail 101 west to the Alpine Way Trail heading toward Marshall Lake. After climbing 1,800 vertical feet in just about four miles on the trail, before Marshall Lake, bear left (west) onto a well-beaten but unmarked footpath that’s usually blocked by a log; this unmaintained user trail climbs steeply into the cirque between Thompson and Williams peaks. The lake below Thompson’s headwall is a good enough destination by itself for a frigid and brief swim—it usually has blocks of ice floating in it well into July.
Continue up and scramble to the Thompson-Williams saddle either via its south end (easy when it’s dry rock, potentially dangerous when snow-covered) or the much steeper, usually dry, exposed fourth-class cliff at the north end of the saddle (find the line of least resistance ascending very exposed ledges angling up and left). Traverse the talus below Thompson’s west face (farther than you might think) to the gully separating Thompson from its 10,000-foot neighbor to the south, Mickey’s Spire. Then follow the steep, often loose, use footpath to the summit. Return the same way.
Read all of this story and ALL stories at The Big Outside,
plus get gear discounts and a FREE e-guide! Join now!
Alice Lake
Among other lakes reachable in a day, I’d suggest Alice Lake at 8,598 feet, because it’s a gorgeous spot, there’s more scenic hiking above it, and the hike to Alice ascends a really pretty valley flanked by cliffs and spires. In early summer, the lower ford of the creek draining Alice Lake can be exciting or potentially dangerous (the next ford upstream is shorter and often has a log across it). You can avoid both fords by following a faint, sporadically cairned use path that begins where the maintained trail crosses the creek at the lower ford; the sometimes-faint use path stays on the north side of the creek and rejoins the maintained trail above the second (higher) ford.
From Tin Cup Trailhead at the northeast corner of Pettit Lake, it’s 5.3 miles and a bit over 1,600 feet to Alice Lake. It’s another mile with not much more climbing to Twin Lakes, and then a half-mile and about 400 feet up to the approximately 9,200-foot pass on the Alice-Toxaway Divide, with a killer view of the jagged peaks above Twin Lakes.
Backpacking Trips
The Sawtooths have few on-trail, multi-day loop hikes. Many multi-day hikes require short shuttles between trailheads (some of which can be done with a bike). My suggestions below assume moderate days of seven to nine miles a day, but I mention multiple campsite options to allow you to plan shorter or longer days.
See the best of the Sawtooths using my expert e-guide to the best backpacking trip in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains!
Weekend Hike: Alice Lake-Toxaway Lake Loop
This 17-mile loop from the Tin Cup Trailhead on Pettit Lake is popular as an overnight or two-night trip for incredible views and campsites on stunning, high lakes. (This was my son’s first real backpacking trip, at age six.) There are stellar campsites at Alice Lake, Twin Lakes, and Toxaway Lake; you might decide between the first two locales just depending on what time you start the trek and whether other backpackers have beaten you to the sites at Alice Lake. Hike it clockwise because the stretch from Farley Lake back to Pettit Lake is the least interesting, sometimes hot, and dusty, and better to walk down than up.
Do you like hiking or running long loops in the mountains? This one follows good trails and fit hikers and runners can do it in a day—but in July or August, I suggest an early start for cooler temps. September is often ideal.
After the Sawtooths, hike the other nine of “America’s Top 10 Best Backpacking Trips.”
Click here now for my expert e-guide to the best backpacking trip in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains!
See all of my stories about the Sawtooths, including “5 Reasons You Must Backpack Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains,” “Mountain Lakes of Idaho’s Sawtooths—A Photo Gallery,” “The Best of Idaho’s Sawtooths: Backpacking Redfish to Pettit,” “Sawtooth Jewels: Backpacking to Alice, Hell Roaring, and Imogene Lakes,” and “Going After Goals: Backpacking in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains.”
First, thank you Michael for you inspiration to hike the Sawtooths, and the White Clouds. And secondly thank you for your assistance in planning 11 days of backpacking with five friends. We all live close to Vancouver BC but this was our first adventure in Idaho.
This was also my first extended backpack trip since returning from trekking/climbing the two highest peaks in Mongolia (three others were denied by unseasonably wintery weather) in August of 2019. Then the pandemic and in early 2021 I was diagnosed with heart issues. Two and half years later, with the good fortune of a very good recovery from the heart issues, I was still filled with anxiety as I left home. Most of it was centered around the possibility of not being able to hike for five and then six days at elevations of up to 3000+ metres (10,000+ ft). That I had been to over 6200 metres (20,000+) previously meant nothing.
Our first hike we chose to hike the Pettit/Alice/Edna/Cramer/Baron/Redfish lakes route. Our rationale for starting at Pettit was a bunch of mainly 60+ (I am 73) sea level decided to ‘ease’ into the adventure. The hike to Alice Lake was a pleasant introduction to the Sawtooths. Shortly after crawling into our tents we welcomed by a nasty thunderstorm that lasted for about an hour clobbering us with hail and torrential rain. Before long I heard “I am flooded!” Scrambling out of my sleeping bag I joined my friends to find two of our party with soggy and floating tents. We quickly got them moved and helped sort out the soggy mess. It was getting too late to pack up and hike out so the dry folks shared clothes to help them get through the night in the best of comfort.
The morning brought sunshine which not only lifted soggy spirits but started to dry out wet gear. Our wet compatriots kept their spirits high and chose to continue on with our proposed itinerary. The weather and the landscape improved with each day.
I have had the good fortune to trek and backpack in several of the great mountain ranges on this planet, including the Alps, Himalaya, Andes, Karakorum, Rockies, Pamir and more. Except for the Karakorum, the Sawtooth are the most consistently dramatic and spectacular I have experienced. The magnificent peaks are complimented with some of the most stunning alpine lakes.
Completing the hike from Monday to Friday meant we missed the weekend crush but still met many people from various places in the US, especially folks from the East Coast who were reveling in the dramatic beauty.
Our adventure was not over. A couple days of rest and resupply around Stanley including a trip to Ketchum to pick up a new air mattress to replace mine that had started to leak. A couple times per night was manageable but within a couple days I was having to re-inflate the mattress five or more times.
Our White Clouds hike was an in-and-out affair as some of our folks did not want to engage in a loop that involved approximately a day and a half of route finding from the Windy Devil Pass at the head of the Chain Lakes Basin to the Fourth of July Lake.
The first couple days involved walking through extensive patch’s of burned forest. For me, burned forests are a mixed blessing. True the loss of a vibrant forest is tough to reconcile but fire is just one of Nature’s natural events that create rebirth of an ecosystem. An incredibly vital part of natural processes and vibrancy. Another benefit is we were offered many peek a boo views of the stately White Cloud mountains.
The White Clouds are more like a well written novel that builds. The beauty of jaw-dropping vistas builds and builds as one crosses pass after pass and works their way up to the end of the Chain Lakes Basin. From speaking with a few folks who had completed the Fourth of July Lake to Windy Devil Pass the climax was actually up there.
The White Clouds are less trammeled than the Sawtooths. That provided a special value to this area. While they are a stately mountain range they are not as consistently dramatic as the Sawtooth mountains.
My entire group were very impressed with their first visit to these areas. Another enjoyed benefit of backpacking in these mountains is being able to avoid the hassle and constrictions of having to obtain a permit.
One concerning factor, especially in the Sawtooths, is the ever-present and increasing signs of human waste, especially around the camping areas. We would have used the WAG bags but none were available in the box at the trailhead.
All of us owe a debt of gratitude to those who had the wisdom and courage to protect this marvelous area. It would be a shame if the popularity of the area results in it being degraded by those who love it.
Hi John,
I’m very happy to had such a successful trip and have recovered so well from your heart problems. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and report and your concerns about human impact on the Sawtooths (and all popular backcountry areas). Everyone must make the small effort to walk at least 200 meters from all water bodies and trails to dig their cathole and do their business, then bury it sufficiently and carry out all used toilet paper.
I really love this page and gained a lot of information. I would love any help you are willing to provide. I am planning a first-time Sawtooth trip for this August. There will be 3 experienced backpacker who would like to speed a max of 4 nights on the trail. We are looking for solitude yet would very much like to avoid bears at all costs.
Thanks for any help you could provide.
Avi
Hi Avi,
I can certainly help you with that. I’ll email you separately with details about my Custom Trip Planning.
Hey Michael! Curious about your thoughts on a hiking/backpacking trip in early May in the Sawtooth’s – too early? Any specific areas that may be better snow and camping wise for a May trip? Thanks!
Hi Jesse,
Definitely much too early. I’ve backpacked into the Sawtooths in late June and hit snow around 8,000 feet; in May the snow level will be down at or not much higher than many trailheads. You could reach some campgrounds in May (and not have much company at them) but even on trails that get more sunshine, you wouldn’t get far before reaching a shaded aspect and suddenly encountering three feet of snow that’s either treacherously icy or so soft you’re postholing into it. Wait until mid-July, at least.
Good luck.
Hi. I’m an avid backpacker in both Wash state and California and I’m seeking for backpacking trip in Sawtooth for a few days. Which trail(s) do you recommend?
Thanks in advance.
Hi Dolph,
All of them! Seriously, there’s an extensive trail system with many options for distance and remoteness. Besides the suggestions above, I’d urge you to check out “this menu of all stories about backpacking in Idaho’s Sawtooths at The Big Outside and my e-guide “The Best Backpacking Trip in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains.”
I can give you a personalized trip plan for the kind of backpacking trip you tell me that you want to take there. See my Custom Trip Planning page to learn how I can help you.
Thanks for the question and good luck.
Hi Michael,
I just purchased your Sawtooth eguide. I noticed that it states its 36 mile point to point. I was under the impression it was a 70 mile loop. What’s the difference in your route versus the loop? Is the signage and/or blazes well marked as I sometimes get directional challenged. I will be flying into Boise, do you know of any shuttle services and/or best economic way to get from the airport to the trailhead? I will be doing the loop or perhaps the guide you sent the last week of July…anything weather wise or animal wise that should be a concern at this time?
Thanks for any info you can share!
Lisa
Hi Lisa,
Thanks for buying my e-guide “The Best Backpacking Trip in Idaho’s Sawtooths Mountains.” That trip is 36 miles, as the description on my E-guides page indicates. I’m not sure what “loop” you’re referring to so I can’t answer that question. But I’m very familiar with the Sawtooths and I do believe the trip in that e-guide is the best in those beautiful mountains.
Read through the entire e-guide as you will see information on traveling, including shuttle services, bears and other animals, as well as on the peak season for backpacking. Late July is a good time to go there.
Have a great hike!
Hey man, these are all great suggestions. I just got back from a hike starting at Redfish lake ending at Lake petitte and WOW!! We camped at Alpine Lake, Hidden Lake, Toxaway Lake, and Alice lake. What an epic adventure!!
Thanks, Matthew. You picked a great route through the Sawtooths. There’s much more exploring you could do, too, especially deeper into the interior of the range. Click here to learn how I can help you plan your next trip in the Sawtooths or any trip you read about at my blog.
Keep in touch!
Great article. Question: What does the upper Fishhook Creek look like? Is there a use trail or is it bushwhacking the whole way? The alpine topography at the top of that drainage looks sweet! Any input welcome!
Hi Nat,
Just reading the name Fishhook Creek sends a shudder through me. I have been through there on various occasions and it has never been pleasant and often miserable, to be honest. There is a use trail leading partway up the north side of that valley from the end of the maintained spur trail, but it disappears in the flats. Beyond that, as the terrain gets steeper, you run into very dense forest and some pretty bad bushwhacking, not to mention cliff bands and convoluted terrain that’s difficult at best to navigate, with short sight lines because you’re in forest.
The upper end of the Fishhook drainage is wonderful alpine terrain once you get above the forest. I’ve been through there multiple times to scramble some peaks. It’s rough off-trail hiking with no real use trails and challenging navigation, but in good weather you can often see where you want to go. There are three or four better ways to approach those peaks and hanging valleys that are much better than Fishhook and ways to connect existing trails on the perimeter of that area in order to hike a loop or traverse. The summits in that corner of the Sawtooths have amazing vistas and some are fun hikes with some third-class scrambling, all of them strenuous, big days, of course. You certainly won’t run into many people up there, if any.
With a good eye for reading a map for possible routes, you might be able to figure out where to go up there. But see my Custom Trip Planning page to learn how I could help you plan a route.
Thanks for the good question and keep in touch.
Hello from Philadelphia! I have been reading your blog in anticipation of a 3-night, 4-day backpacking trip I am planning in the Sawtooth Wilderness in early September. I will be traveling with a group of four. I am trying to decide between doing the Alice-Toxaway loop with a detour to Imogene for 1 night, or doing a hike from Redfish Lake to Alpine, Baron, and Cramer lakes. Having done both routes, do you have any advice on which would be better for us? They both look beautiful!
Hi Rhiannon,
Good for you. Both areas are certainly beautiful. Alice Lake is one of the busiest in the Sawtooths, especially on weekends in August and often into September, so you might consider that, depending on your exact dates. Baron and Cramer are also among the nicest lakes in the Sawtooths and I’ve seen Cramer busy on a weekend in August.
You can conceivably link up both areas in a four-day hike. Check out my e-guide “The Best Backpacking Trip in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains.”
And I can help you plan a customized itinerary based on your group. See my Custom Trip Planning page to learn how.
Thanks for the question and keep in touch.
Hi – I’m planning an overnight backpacking with my family of 4 for mid-July. We are experienced backpackers, and our youngest handles about 4 miles really well. I’m looking hard at camping at Alpine Lake (the one below Sawtooth Lake), setting up camp, then hiking on up to Sawtooth Lake. Looking at google maps, Alpine Lake looks to sit in a deep bowl. I’ve read there are a few areas to camp at that lake, is that so? And do you know which shore the flatter areas are?
Hi Kari,
Alpine Lake has established campsites and sees backpackers overnighting fairly regularly. I’m told there was even a pit toilet there but it may have been removed or be in disrepair. It’s good trails from Iron Creek Trailhead to Alpine Lake and that puts you in a position for a morning visit to Sawtooth Lake, when it’s often glassy and very pretty.
Have a good hike.
Hey Michael, what are your thoughts on early to mid June (say June 10) backpacking in the Sawtooths? Will snow be impassable for most of these trips or packed sufficiently for backpackers?
Hi Karen,
I get that question regarding many Western mountains, and the answer is basically the same as it is for the Sawtooths. In a typical year, the ground is mostly snow-covered above roughly 8,000 feet (depending on amount of sun exposure, meaning aspect and shade), making hiking difficult because you’ll posthole into soft snow, until around mid-July. I’ve backpacked in June before and it’s possible to hike over snow that’s firmly frozen in mornings (you may need traction devices on your boots) but it’s soft by late morning or afternoon, and the coverage gets spotty at some point in the calendar: two feet deep for 100 feet, bare ground for 40 feet, then two feet of snow again, that kind of thing. Hiking to and crossing passes can be dangerous because of the possibility of a long slide on snow or having to get over or around a snow cornice at the pass.
The two photos of Alice Lake (above) were taken on the same trip in the last week of June. You can see the lakes remain partly frozen and the ground mostly snow-covered.
Mid-July is generally the safe bet for finding trails mostly snow-free. It can open up earlier in years with less snow in winter and spring and warmer temps from spring into summer. That may happen this year, but it’s a little early now to know. I’d say you’re practically guaranteed to encounter a lot of snow in mid-June.
Check out these webcams in Stanley, Idaho, in the Sawtooth Valley, and you’ll get some sense of the current snow cover.
I hope that’s helpful.
Looking at doing a Sawtooths trip in early August; I have seven days to work with. Is there a loop or series of trails you’d recommend to see the “best of” the Sawtooths using that amount of time? I’m not averse to doing a fair amount of mileage each day to see the beauty of the area. Thanks for your help and the great information!
Hi Brett,
Thanks for the question, I’m so glad you asked. You should get my downloadable e-guide to “The Best Backpacking Trip in Idaho’s Sawtooth Mountains,,” which answers your question and describes a primary route that’s five days and variations of that route ranging from four to seven days, and tells you all you need to know to plan and pull off that trip. It hits what I consider the very best area of the Sawtooths for mountain lakes, beautiful alpine cirques and high passes.
And of course, if you’d like my direct help with planning that trip, including answering all of your questions, see my Custom Trip Planning page to learn how I can do that for you.
Enjoy. This is the perfect time of year to hit the Sawtooths.
Michael
I’ve really enjoyed reading your blog. It has been very informative.
I am planning a backpacking trip for the end of August to the Sawtooths. I really love a good loop and prefer high mileage days (15-20).
My plan is Grandjean>sawtooth lake>redfish lake>hell roaring lake>Edna lake>baron lakes and back to Grandjean .
Im wondering if you have any recommendations for most scenic campsites along that route or would recommend any route changes to allow better scenery?
Thanks
Erin
Hi Erin,
Thanks for the nice words about my blog, I appreciate that.
Late August is an ideal time in the Sawtooths. I’ve backpacked the areas on your planned loop and you’re definitely hitting some of the nicest lakes. I’d would honestly recommend a different route to you that would hit many of the best mountain lakes and high passes in the Sawtooths, but avoid some of the trails on your loop that I think aren’t as interesting.
I could help you plan out all of the details of an amazing hike in the Sawtooths. See my Custom Trip Planning page to learn how I can help you out.
Thanks for the question.
What is the best map for backpacking in the Sawtooths ?
Thanks
Ed
Hi Ed,
Thanks for asking. I use a couple of Sawtooths trail maps, neither of them perfect, but both adequate for hiking trails: the Earthwalk Press Sawtooth Wilderness map (found in many stores in Idaho and online), and the Sawtooth & White Cloud Mountains map from adventuremaps.net. I think the best complete hiking guide to the Sawtooths is the “Exploring the Sawtooths” guide from Idaho River Publications.
Hi Michael,
What do you think about the Nat Geo map? We are heading out to the Sawtooths in a couple weeks, but can’t find much commentary on that set.
Would also be curious if you have a recommended map for the Wallowa-Whitman NF? We have CalTopo, so can just print from that if all else fails.
Thank you.
Kind regards,
Oliver
Hi Oliver,
Good question, thanks for asking. I’ve used probably every commercial trail map of the Sawtooths and I do think the best one is the one you’re asking about, the National Geographic/Trails Illustrated Sawtooth National Recreation Area map no. 870. It has convenient mileage distances marked for trail segments and good contour details for backpacking or dayhiking.
However, online mapping services like caltopo and Mytopo are also good.
Have a good trip in the Sawtooths.
Michael
Michael,
In early August my wife and daughters (ages 14 and 11) and I are rafting the Middle Fork of the Salmon, and I’ve built in a couple days for backpacking in the Sawtooths, a range I’ve never explored before. The Alice-Toxaway Loop seems like the obvious 3-day family trip, or maybe just basecamping at one of those lakes. Do you have any extra thoughts about particularly great camping spots at Alice or Toxaway or elsewhere in the neighborhood? Hell Roaring Lake looks like a good, mellower option but it seems that the trail in is relatively mundane and the lake is a bit buggy; any thoughts on that?
Also, I’ve found that the frontcountry experience can do a lot to frame up a good backcountry experience. We’ll be flying in and out of Boise. Do you have any favorite places in Boise for tacos or burgers? Or maybe some tips for a road trip between Boise and Salmon, ID?
Thanks for your insights, and keep up the great writing!
George
Hi George,
Great plan to combine the Middle Fork of the Salmon and the Sawtooths in one trip! Not long ago I posted my story (perhaps you saw it) about my family’s second trip on the Middle Fork, and we already have dates for our next Middle Fork trip. It’s an exceptional adventure.
Yes, the Alice-Toxaway loop is a super three-day family hike with excellent campsites at Alice, Twin, and Toxaway lakes. Hell Roaring is a beautiful lake, but the trail to it is roughly five miles of mundane hiking through forest, and the camping at Hell Roaring is wooded and just okay. Imogene Lake, a bit farther up the trail past Hell Roaring, is gorgeous and has excellent campsites.
Boise has many great places for food downtown and on the edge of downtown. One of my family’s favorite has long been Highlands Hollow, just off Bogus Basin Road, which has good burgers and other reasonably priced meals and the best fries in town (although Boise Fry Company downtown is also really good). Many good choices. Walk around the downtown and explore, you’ll like it.
The road trip from Boise north to Stanley and then Salmon is one of the most scenic drives in the West, especially along the Salmon River from Stanley to Salmon. The loop from Boise to Stanley and then south through Ketchum/Sun Valley and Fairfield back to Boise is also very nice. Check out idahohotsprings.com.
Thanks Michael. Your writing about the Middle Fork was influential, for sure.
Wonderful, thanks for saying so, George.
On my first backpacking trip in Idaho I did a similar hike to your 3-4 day suggestion. We took the wooden trail between McDonald Lake and Yellow Belly Lake, which you said you hadn’t done yet. It is not interesting, and not the most fun way to end a hike but necessary if you’re doing the loop. After you cross the creek draining McDonald Lake the climb up that ridge is very steep going up and down. It is then a long walk on forest roads to connect with the Lower Hell Roaring Trailhead. I think it actually would’ve been more fun to stay around the Imogene Divide area and backtrack to Hell Roaring instead of completing the loop. We barely stopped at Bowknot and Farley Lakes because of time, but as you said that section is drier and hotter and not as scenic.
I would say that most guidebooks I read took the Edith Lake route to Toxaway Lake after descending Imogene Divide. Instead we stayed on the high trail and went up Sand Mountain Pass, then dropped to Rendezvous Lake/Lake 8861′ which was an awesome campsite and had spectacular colors at sunset. If I would do it again I would basecamp at Imogene Lake and take a couple days to explore the high lakes below Payette Peak and Mt. Cramer. I hear Profile Lake is awesome.
Great suggestions, Zachary, thanks.